How Did Thanksgiving Begin, What Do Americans Serve

Russell Pruner  |  November 20, 2026

Blog

How Did Thanksgiving Begin, What Do Americans Serve

Greenwich, CT real estate is my business, but Thanksgiving is about the people around the table, so here is a short guide to where the holiday came from, what ends up on the plate, and how to  enjoy the day with family and friends. If the day also gets you thinking about your own home  and what comes next, call me, because the numbers behind that question are worth going through together. 

How Did Thanksgiving Begin? 

The story most Americans know starts in 1621 at Plymouth, where the colonists held a harvest  feast and the Wampanoag joined them. The Wampanoag already had their own traditions of  giving thanks, and the colonists were celebrating in the style of an English harvest festival.  Historians believe the meal included fowl, venison brought by the Wampanoag, and probably  fish and shellfish. Turkey may not have been the star at all. 

Days of thanksgiving kept appearing across the colonies after that, but not on a shared date. The  Continental Congress proclaimed a national day of thanksgiving in 1777, and President  Washington declared one in 1789. Later, the writer and editor Sarah Josepha Hale spent years  lobbying for a national holiday, and in 1863 President Lincoln proclaimed a day of thanksgiving  for Thursday, November 26, in the middle of the Civil War. That was the same calendar date as  this year's Thanksgiving. 

The date moved around for decades after that. President Roosevelt shifted it to the third  Thursday for three years to lengthen the Christmas shopping season, which caused a public  argument. Congress settled it in 1941 with the fourth Thursday of November, where it has  stayed. 

What Foods Are Most Popular on Thanksgiving? 

Turkey still anchors the table. The National Turkey Federation has long estimated that about  88% of Americans eat turkey on Thanksgiving. The surprise is that many people look forward to  the sides more than the bird. In Campbell's 2025 survey of 5,000 Americans, 63% said they  prefer the sides to the main course, and 85% said leftovers are one of the best parts of the  holiday. 

The 2025 side dish ranking, from most to least popular, ran like this: 

• Stuffing or dressing, which ranked first in 38 states 

• Mashed potatoes 

• Sweet potatoes 

• Macaroni and cheese, which has climbed as younger diners treat it as a holiday staple

• Green bean casserole 

 

For dessert, a separate 2025 Savings.com survey found pumpkin pie leading with 42% of the  vote, followed by apple and pecan. The same survey found that 49% prefer stuffing cooked  outside the turkey, and 43% favor fresh cranberry sauce over canned. 

What Is the Best Way to Get Through the Day With Family and Friends? 

The American Psychological Association has reported that 41% of U.S. adults say their stress  rises during the holiday season, so if the day feels like work, you are in good company. The  advice from psychologists and family-communication experts is surprisingly consistent: 

• Agree on off-limits topics ahead of time. Politics, old family disputes, and questions  about someone's personal life are the usual culprits. 

• Give the day some structure. A set meal time, a game, a group walk, or a gratitude round  gives everyone something to do besides argue. 

• Do not try to change anyone's mind at the table. It rarely works, and it costs you your  own peace of mind. 

• Set a boundary politely and early, and step outside for a few minutes when you need to  reset. 

• Say yes when someone offers to bring dessert or wash dishes. The day is about time  together, not a perfect turkey. 

• Know when to leave. A time limit, even an unspoken one, keeps a good day from  stretching into a tense one. 

If You Are Hosting, What Helps Most? 

The host sets the tone. Plan the seating so that people who clash are not side by side, have  something ready for the children to do, and decide in advance who is handling what. A small  amount of planning removes most of the chaos. And give yourself some room to enjoy it,  because hosts who put themselves last tend to run out of patience first. 

What If the Conversation Turns to the Family Home? 

Holiday gatherings are often when families start talking about what comes next for a house,  whether that is a parent's long-held home or your own. There is no need to settle anything at the  table. A first step can be as simple as writing down your questions and calling me afterward. I  would rather help you gather clear information at a comfortable pace than see anyone feel  rushed.

Thanksgiving at a Glance

 

Whatever your table looks like this year, I hope it is a good one. This article is general  information and not legal, tax, or financial advice. If you would like to talk about your home,  your timing, or what a move could look like, I am at 203-524-4998 or  

[email protected], and I will give you an honest answer without any pressure.

Russell Pruner | Senior Real Estate Specialist | CRS | GRI | SRES | Six-Time GAR-GMLS President | 40+ Years  in Greenwich | Greenwich Streets Team at Compass 

The Greenwich Streets Team has been named RealTrends Verified for 2026, placing them among the top 1.5% of real estate  professionals nationwide. 

 

Frequently Asked Questions 

When is Thanksgiving in 2026?

Thursday, November 26, 2026. Congress settled the date in  1941 as the fourth Thursday of November, which accounts for years when the month has five  Thursdays. 

Who proclaimed the first national Thanksgiving?

The Continental Congress proclaimed a  national day of thanksgiving in 1777, and President George Washington declared one in 1789.  President Abraham Lincoln's 1863 proclamation is the one that led to the annual national  holiday. 

What is the most popular Thanksgiving side dish?

In Campbell's 2025 survey of 5,000  Americans, stuffing (or dressing) ranked first, followed by mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes,  macaroni and cheese, and green bean casserole. 

What is the most popular Thanksgiving pie?

Pumpkin pie, which took 42% of the vote in a  2025 Savings.com survey, ahead of apple and pecan. 

How can I keep the peace at a family Thanksgiving?

Agree ahead of time which topics are off limits, give the day some structure with a meal time and an activity, and give yourself permission to step away for a few minutes. Psychologists also advise against trying to change anyone's mind at the table. 

Last updated: November 2026 

 

Sources: Britannica, Thanksgiving Day; Congressional Research Service, Thanksgiving: Fact Sheet; Campbell's  2025 State of the Sides survey; Savings.com 2025 Thanksgiving survey; National Turkey Federation; American  Psychological Association; guidance from psychologists and family-communication experts at UVA Health, West  Virginia University, and the University of Michigan. 

 

 

Work With Us

We are a dedicated group of Greenwich natives. We have a deep passion for our hometown and enjoy everything the town offers its residents from the beach front to the backcountry. That is why we don’t find you just any home, we find you the right home.